American Commerce Insurance Company Find An AgentJoin Outr Team
Site Search

Online Payments Coming Soon!

Accepting check, credit card and automatic withdrawal payments.



Zip Code:
or 
City:
State:



American Commerce is rated “A+” (Superior) by A.M. Best.

Shape a Bright Future for Your Agency.

Now appointing independent agents in the states of IN, OH, NJ and NY.


Serving Independent Agents for over 60 Years…


Since 1946, American Commerce Insurance Company (ACIC) has become one of America’s leading suppliers of personal lines insurance. Through the years, we’ve listed very carefully to what agencies what. We’ve learned how to gain their business and their confidence, and how to keep it.


Offering Superior Personal Lines Products


  • Home/Condo/Renters
  • Motorcycle
  • Motor Homes
  • Umbrella
  • Private Passenger Automobiles
  • ATVs & Snowmobiles
  • Travel Trailers
  • Watercraft

Please note that not all product types may be available in your state at this time. Speak with an American Commerce Representative to obtain more detailed information.


First Class Service Standards

  • Regionalized marketing and claims presence
  • Specialized agency systems support
  • Fast and friendly personalized service
  • Quality renewal policy reviews
  • Daily payment processing


To apply for an independent agency appointment with American Commerce, complete an on-line application, or contact one of our marketing representatives:

For Indiana,
call Susan Wheeler at (317) 865-1446.

For Ohio,
call Greg Johnson at (614) 308-3220 or
Beth Butts at (614) 308-3249.

For New Jersey,
call Jennifer Ranft at (862) 209-1510.

For New York,
email Greg Duddy..


Expect Excellence



  • Rated "A+" by A.M. Best
  • Exceptional Claim Handling
  • 24/7 Direct Loss Reporting
  • Standard / Preferred auto product
  • 24/7 Direct Loss Reporting
  • Exceptional claims handling and service